X factor has admitted altering the voices of its contestants.
The allegations and admissions come after what some are calling a bodge job of tweaking voices using software known as autotuning. It all started with Gamu Nhengu when she was singing Walking on Sunshine. By all accounts one can tell she is live and then someone cranks up the autotune dial and she becomes, well better! What is worse is that G&S doesn’t get any help from the guy behind the autotune dial. 
In other words the producers are manufacturing the show (as if you didn’t already suspect it) for comedy value and entertainment ratings. Some may call this cheating, an abuse of power, or just how it is.
Indeed, autotuning is apparently common place for musicians in recording studios (but these are musicians who have made it and want to produce records of top quality for their fans). Using such software to adjust live performance, which is then sold as ‘raw talent’ is a little misleading don’t you think?!
So, just what is autotuning? There is a good summary on the BBC which refers to a now lucky blogger who had written about this in the past. I like the analogy that is provided by the BBC:
‘…If you’ve ever removed red-eye from a photograph, or used a spell checker to correct an essay, then you know how computer software can… well, “enhance” your raw material.
Autotune performs exactly the same function with music, by smoothing out sharp or flat notes to make singers pitch perfect.
It is actually a brand name – owned by Antares, a company based “a stone’s throw” from Silicon Valley in California – and there are plenty of competing products that do a similar job…’
It is very popular in the recording studio and some artists use it for special effect if they want to sound like a robot. Think of Cher singing Believe and she is singing with autotune deliberately turned up to maximum to produce the effect.
The general consensus appears to be that in the studio it is common place and is used sparingly to adjust one or two notes. It is a professional tool. But in a series where the fundamental principle is raw talent it really is taking the royal Michael when the producers abuse the system for their own goals. Probably the same mob that rigged the telephone voting on another ITV show.
Anyway, I am off to buy shares in Autotune.
Recent Comments